GuidesMake the creative

How to make us vs them ads

An us-vs-them ad compares your product with an alternative on criteria the buyer cares about. Pick a real customer pain, compare only what you can substantiate, show the contrast visually in a two-column or before-and-after layout, and keep it truthful. Comparative advertising is allowed when it is accurate and not misleading.

Updated November 16, 20265 steps5 min read

Write my next ads →

$1 today. Cancel anytime before day 7.

Build a comparison ad
  1. 1Pick the painChoose a problem buyers have with the alternative.
  2. 2Choose three criteriaPrice, time, effort or result, each one provable.
  3. 3Document the proofKeep the source for every claim in a file.
  4. 4Design the contrastTwo columns, before and after, or a checklist.
  5. 5Test the angleRun against a plain benefits ad.
On this page
  1. Decide what you are comparing against
  2. Choose criteria you can prove
  3. Design the contrast so it reads in a second
  4. Write the copy and check the platform policy
  5. Test the comparison against a plain benefits ad
  6. Questions

Decide what you are comparing against

The alternative does not have to be a named competitor. It can be a category (“hiring an agency”), a method (“doing it in spreadsheets”), or the status quo (“doing nothing”). Unnamed comparisons carry less legal and policy risk and often connect better, because the viewer recognizes their own situation.

To see how competitors position themselves, look through their live ads in the Meta Ads Library and note which criteria they stress. Choose the ones where you are genuinely different, not the ones you wish you were.

Interview a few customers who switched from the alternative, and ask what pushed them. Their words become your rows and your headline. Also listen to why prospects stay with the alternative: those reasons are the objections your comparison has to meet. If the alternative wins on something that matters to the buyer, do not put it in the ad; address it on the landing page where there is room.

Choose criteria you can prove

Pick two to four criteria that the buyer cares about, and state each as a fact: setup time, price model, contract length, support hours, a feature that exists or does not. Subjective claims like “better” or “easier” need a measurement behind them.

Keep a file with the source for every line: a screenshot of the current public price, a dated product page, a customer result you have permission to use. Competitors change prices and features, so recheck before each campaign and remove anything stale. Objective claims in advertising generally need substantiation before you publish.

State comparisons as of a date, such as “prices checked in November,” in a footnote or the landing page, and re-verify each one before every flight. Do not use a competitor’s logo or trademarked name in a way that implies endorsement. If a claim relies on a test or a study, keep the method and the data. A short methods note on the landing page also answers the skeptical visitor who wonders where the numbers came from.

Need the next round of ads?

Pulls competitors’ live ads and breaks down their hooks. Watches your ads for creative fatigue every week.

Design the contrast so it reads in a second

The classic layout is two columns: “Us” and “Them” (or the category name), with check marks and crosses beside the same rows. Alternatives are a before-and-after split, a table of three rows, or a short video that shows both ways of doing the job. Keep the rows few and the type large.

Make your own column visibly the winner without insulting anyone. Mockery wins the scroll and loses the sale. Layout principles are in static ad design, and the sizing sits on the Meta ad specs page.

Use the same row labels on both sides and keep wording neutral for the rival: “Setup: 2 weeks” rather than “Setup: painfully slow.” Use your brand color for your column and a neutral gray for theirs. If you are comparing to a category rather than a company, an illustration of the old way next to the new way avoids naming anyone and can be funnier and safer than a table.

Write the copy and check the platform policy

Lead the headline with the customer’s benefit: “Quotes in minutes, not days.” Use the primary text to name the alternative and the difference. Avoid using competitor trademarks as keywords or in ad text where the platform’s policy forbids it, and read each platform’s current rules on comparative and trademark use before launching.

For search ads, bidding on competitor terms is a separate decision with its own tradeoffs; see bid on competitor keywords. If you are comparing in a landing page, competitor landing pages shows how to study what rivals say.

Ad platforms review comparison claims, and ad copy that makes absolute statements such as “the best” or “number one” may need substantiation. Superlatives you cannot show are the usual cause of disapprovals. If a comparison ad gets rejected, read the stated reason, soften the claim to something you can document, and resubmit rather than re-creating the ad from scratch.

Test the comparison against a plain benefits ad

Comparison ads often do well on audiences already shopping around, and can be lost on cold audiences who have not yet heard of the alternative. Run one against your best benefits ad, split by audience temperature, and judge by cost per result.

Sprites can pull competitors’ live ads from Meta, Google, TikTok and LinkedIn and break down the hooks and offers they use, so your comparison starts from what is actually running. Drafts come back as approval cards you edit.

Pair the comparison ad with a landing page that continues the comparison: the same rows, with more detail and the proof. If the ad compares and the page does not, the click feels like a bait and switch. Keep a note of which competitors’ ads and features you reference, and revisit when they change, since a stale comparison is a liability.

Questions

Are us vs them ads legal?

Comparative advertising is generally allowed when the comparison is truthful, not misleading, and backed by evidence for objective claims. Rules vary by country, so check yours.

Should I name the competitor?

Not necessarily. Comparing against a category or a method avoids most trademark and policy problems and still lands with the buyer.

What are good comparison criteria?

Price model, setup time, contract length, support access and a specific result or feature. Choose rows where your difference is real and documented.

Do us vs them ads work?

They tend to work best with buyers who are already comparing options. Test them against a benefits ad on that audience before you scale.

Where can I find comparison ad examples?

Search ad libraries for competitors in your category and note which ones run for months. Our swipe file and ad libraries collect live examples.

Keep going

Have Sprites write your next ads

  • Pulls competitors’ live ads and breaks down their hooks
  • Writes ad copy and concepts for your offer
  • Watches your ads for creative fatigue every week